Dougherty reflects on “libertine lifestyle” comment years later

Megan Trotter | news editor

Nine years ago, former Duquesne Duke news editor Kaye Burnet got side tracked by a sign on her way to the gym — this led Burnet into a private faculty meeting which coincidentally placed her right at the center of what would become a nationally covered controversy.

On Oct. 22, 2015, Burnet wrote and published a staff editorial expressing dismay about an “ugly” and “unflattering” comment former Duquesne University President Charles Dougherty made about students who live off campus. The article prompted outrage from students, alumni and parents.

In his remark at the faculty meeting two days earlier, Dougherty referred to off-campus students as living a “libertine lifestyle,” and pointed to student’s desire to drink alcohol, do drugs, party and have sex as the reason for low student residency rates on campus.

“We know why they move off-campus,” Dougherty said, according to the staff editorial. “They flaunt [sic] the state liquor laws and they live a libertine lifestyle that is not allowed on campus.”

In the staff editorial headlined “President Dougherty got it wrong about off-campus living,” Burnet stated that more than half of The Duke’s staff at the time lived off campus and that the real reason students moved to other areas was because of price.

“Room and board rates start at $5,000 and can reach $7,000. This means students are spending at least $1,250 each month, which is roughly double what a student renting a house on the South Side spends on rent, utilities and groceries,” the staff editorial said.

Burnet’s staff editorial caught the attention of the Associated Press, which wrote an article which was picked up by more than 40 news outlets across the U.S., including The New York Times and The Washington Post.

The Associated Press article quoted Burnet saying that the remarks “had been met with anger and ‘a lot of frustration’ from students and parents.”

Those angered by Dougherty’s statement and use of the word “libertine,” which is defined as a person who is not restrained by morality with regard to sexual relations or a person of dissolute or promiscuous habits, according to the Oxford Dictionary, turned to social media and left over 60 comments on The Duquesne Duke’s website.

The term “libertine lifestyle” quickly took on a life of its own, and students began making shirts with the slogan on it.

On Oct. 23, Dougherty wrote a letter addressed to former Student Government Association President John Foster in which he stated that comment was made in relation to Duquesne’s recent purchase of Brottier Hall, construction on Des Places Hall and a $100 million investment into Duquesne Towers dormitory.

“I made the point that life off campus allows for greater access to alcohol, sometimes in violation of state law. It also allows for sexual behaviors that we cannot accept on the campus … We know these things from multiple reliable sources,” Dougherty’s letter said. “I did not mean to imply that every student who moves off campus does so for these reasons.”

In the letter, Dougherty apologized to students who thought his remark implied that he carried the belief that all students living off campus behaved in this manner.

Burnet and then Editor-in-Chief Julian Roth wrote a followup news article on Oct. 29, under the headline “Amid calls for apology, Dougherty issues same letter through SGA,” in which The Duke reached out to Dougherty for an interview — he declined.

The Duke also requested the transcription from the meeting but was told the request could not be granted because that portion of the meeting had not been recorded.

“At the time, and the administration … wasn’t too happy about The Duke’s reporting,” Routh said. “The staff did such an incredible job of balancing student interests while also telling the truth and not being afraid to criticize an administration for doing something that we thought did not serve the students in the best interest.”

For almost a decade the letter was the only comment Dougherty made regarding the incident, until he once again addressed it in an interview with The Duke on Wednesday.

“This remark happened at a meeting that was exclusive for faculty and administration. Somebody from [The Duke] came in, should not have been there, and I made a remark about something, probably I overstated a position, and afterwards, I more or less apologized for it,” Dougherty said on Wednesday.

According to Foster, many students expected Doughtery to meet with them and further address the comment, rather than turning to SGA as a middleman.

“He stood by his statement,” Foster said. “Students just felt that it was a half hearted apology, or was sorry that you were upset by what I said. And students were just like, ‘Well, you didn’t retract that statement.’”

Burnet remembered sitting in the meeting, shocked to hear the president openly share this opinion.

“I was just like ‘oh my goodness, this is what the president of the university thinks of us is that we’re a bunch of ne’er-do-wells,’” Burnet said.

Dougherty said the article ran in the newspaper as if it were a big deal, but to him it was “a tiny thing.”

During his presidency, one of Dougherty’s main goals was to increase admission beyond just high schools in the Western Pennsylvania area.

“There had to be more housing. There had to be housing that had suites, because people didn’t want to live in the old dormitory styles anymore. So all of that was evolving at the time to make living on campus not only an option, but an attractive option,” he said.

Foster said that the controversy did open Duquesne up to a campus-wide discussion about why students lived off campus and the Student Life and Commuter Affairs offices put out informal surveys asking students why they did not live on campus.

“I did issue a statement,” Dougherty said. “It was as close to an apology as I got by saying ‘I misspoke, I shouldn’t have said that.’ But there was a certain reality, and I took it back, and we moved on. And like I say, in terms of all the good things that happened in my 15 years, I barely, barely even remember this moment.”

Burnet and Routh, both recall covering the libertines controversy as one of their most important stories they wrote while working at The Duke.

Note: John Foster currently works for the U.S. Department of State. Foster interviewed in his personal capacity. The views expressed do not reflect the official policy or position of the U.S. government or Department of State.

Note: Eliyahu Gasson contributed to this report.

Leave a Comment