Ember Duke | layout editor
Wednesday nights in The Duke newsroom are always a bit rowdy, sometimes lewd jokes get thrown around, sometimes the sleep deprivation and deadline pressure turn into delusional rambling, other times, an inappropriate word will find its way into an article or horoscope, for the sole purpose of pushing advisor Paula Ward’s buttons. The light fun, however, doesn’t make it to the newsstand — one of the most controversial outliers is an April Fool’s Day issue from 1984.
For roughly the first half of The Duke’s early publication history, an annual April Fool’s Day issue, poking fun at the campus community, was tradition. The explicit nature of the 1984 issue, The Weekly Douche, and the subsequent battle between the editorial staff and university administration ended the tradition.
Donald Nesti, university president from 1980-1988, wrote in a report to the board of directors in May 1984 that the issue was “unfortunately characterized by an assault on many of the values which we hold to be important at the university.” Nesti, who was alluded to in the issue as Reverend Donny Nesticles, shut down the paper for its remaining issue of the academic year.
Linda Shirey Colleran, editor-in-chief at the time, remembers putting the issue together without direct supervision of a faculty member, but said there was never any malicious intent behind the parody issue. She said some of the final jokes added on production night were what pushed the envelope more.
“I love comedy that is no holds barred,” she said. “The more extreme it got … I could see the humor in it, and there were some people on the editorial desk and whole group that were saying, ‘whoa, whoa, whoa, that’s too far’ … Some of that final stuff by morning, I did go, ‘Oh, holy heck’ but 99% of it I still think is hilarious to this day.”
Though Colleran said she still doesn’t regret publishing it, she did grow from it.
“If I learned one thing, it would be, and I say this to my kids now … you have to forgive foolishness. I mean, you just need to be kind, particularly to those starting out,” she said.
The issue didn’t hold its punches, satirising articles about several student organizations, including the SGA, students, faculty, nuns and administrators — all published under pseudonyms, such as Jail Bait or Sally Spankme. They also used fake names for all individuals and called the university Duke Wayne.
One article is titled “Duke Wayne’s nuns display wild partying,” followed by a narrative of the ‘reporter’ smoking marijuana with the nuns. The issue’s second page titled “Bulging Briefs” has several vignettes about sexually explicit on-campus events — under the sub-head “Chests are nice” the copy reads: “A meeting will be held in room 969 of the Onion to discuss what to call the female breast next Tuesday. Delegates will decide …” Paula still won’t let us say.
Down to the cutlines, the jokes ink every page. One cutline with a photo of a man in uniform preparing food reads: “I don’t know what the hell it is. Since it ain’t movin’ it must be lunch!”
“The one guy that we called ‘Fitzdoody’ … He never thought that was funny at all. He was again, one I remember from that disciplinary hearing just glaring at me the whole time,” Colleran said.
The Student Government Association, which tried to lead the initial disciplinary action before administration took charge, resolved to have the paper publicly apologize, face a judicial board and continue publishing with ethics guidelines designed in collaboration with The Society of Professional Journalists and faculty advisors.
“Suspending the final issue of the Duquesne Duke by the Reverend Donald S. Nesti, C.S.Sp., University President, was found by many students to be an act of blatant censorship; it was also in direct conflict with a Student Government Association Senate resolution,” the SGA report from May 1984 said.
The report also opposed a student publication oversight committee composed of the SGA president, vice president of student affairs, vice president of university relations, the journalism department chairperson and The Duke editor-in-chief.
“The S.G.A. does not support any University Committee which would have the prerogative of prior copy or any such censorship of The Duke or any student publication,” the report said.
Colleran said an ACLU lawyer represented her and The Duke in the judiciary hearing, arguing that the university’s choice to shut-down the paper was an impediment to its editorial independence. Nesti wanted the students expelled, but his sentiment was not shared by the rest of the judicial board, according to The Spirit That Gives Life: The History of Duquesne University.
Chris Fletcher, co-associate editor at the time, said the way it was all handled made the backlash worse for the university. However, it was also a good lesson for The Duke staff, he said.
“Even though what we did was not any kind of journalism, the minute you shut down the newspaper for the rest of the year, you automatically raise your First Amendment questions,” Fletcher said.
The suspension stuck, but spurred some editors to publish a one-page issue The Duquesne Duchess with printing help from The Pitts News, said Fletcher. Publishing funds of $250 were donated by alumni, the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, the Pittsburgh Press and three local TV stations, according to The Spirit That Gives Life.
Fletcher cited editorial frustration over lack of campus interest in the paper and the National Lampoon magazine as possible inspiring factors for the issue.
The Duke also had to apologize in the faculty-administration publication Spirit and give 10 free half-page ads to offended campus groups the following year, which accounted for one-fifth of the yearly budget, according to an article by The Duke the following year.
John Wdowiak, the 1985 editor-in-chief, said he doesn’t remember the lost finances or judiciary action negatively affecting the paper the following year, but he did feel it was followed more closely by readership.
“I think in hindsight it was a good thing because it simply raised the profile of the paper and its awareness, and we all believed, as a staff, that that was a good thing, and people were now paying that much more attention to their student newspaper,” Wdowiak said.
His year as editor, no April Fool’s issue ran. There have since been scattered attempts at April Fool’s humor, but never as a regular occurrence.
“We were conscious that maybe people were paying a little bit closer attention to what we were doing. So we probably made a decision to not have one on purpose and intentionally,” he said.
The issue — and all others referenced in this centennial issue — can be found in The Duke’s digital archives through the Gumberg Library website.
