Sports section’s passion burns through a century

Michael O’Grady | sports editor 

“They had Manhattan, the Bronx, and Staten Island too … all at their feet Saturday night in the town where an adjective is the least-used item of the good writer’s vocabulary,” wrote Tammy Gray on March 25, 1955. “The press-box boys just couldn’t use enough superlatives, while the loyal fans who made the safari to Peter Stuyvesant’s island said ‘they knew it all the time.’”

That is the full first paragraph of Gray’s story on what was arguably Duquesne athletics’ greatest-ever accomplishment: a 70-58 win by the men’s basketball team over Dayton at the old Madison Square Garden to win the 1955 National Invitation Tournament, back when that and the NCAA Tournament were more equal in prominence. Gray captures the glory of the event, yet in 2025 there would be some issues with grammar and punctuation. There’s an Oxford comma after “the Bronx,” as well as a hyphen between “press” and “box.” Also, the Peter Stuyvesant reference is knowledgeable yet bold for a university newspaper where most students are from Western Pennsylvania.

In the 70 years since those words were printed, much has changed in sports journalism at The Duke, yet much has stayed the same. Just less than a year ago, The Duke was back in New York (albeit across the East River) to cover a monumental Atlantic 10 Conference victory for men’s basketball. Typewriters may have been exchanged for keyboards, and lexicons have mutated along the line, but the passion for covering the Bluff’s sports, good and bad, has always been there.

It has been there since the very first Duke issue on March 5, 1925; in fact, it lays claim to the publication’s first-ever headline. The article is titled “Duke Rooters to Accompany Team,” and it describes a group of around 400 Duquesne students chartering a train to catch the men’s team for a big game against Geneva College in Beaver Falls. Unfortunately, the writer is lost to time, but they wrote as if speaking to the reader, asking questions and using several exclamation points in language that is closer to what Thomas Jefferson used in the Declaration of Independence than a 2025 Duke edition. “LET’S SEE YOU MAKE ‘EM AND OUT-ROOT GENEVA,” the article ends, all-caps and all.

The Duke has had at least one page dedicated to sports since the early days of the newspaper, and its first known sports editor was Charles O. Rice in the fall of 1928. Rice pioneered a dedicated sports editor’s column called “Rice Flakes,” and though not every editor has followed his lead in the near-century since, columns have been prevalent in different volumes over the years. A discontinued portion of sports reporting in The Duke has been covering intramural sports, whether between independent teams, fraternities or social clubs. There was a time when there was in-depth coverage on nearly every intramural game, which is how radio personality Mark Madden made his chops.

“I don’t think he missed one intramural hockey game,” late-1970s sports editor John Schmidt said. “There would be rings of paper he’d send me, and I’d tell him, ‘Mark, I can’t fit all of this.’”

Schmidt’s time writing for The Duke included some major highlights for the university’s sports, especially the football and men’s basketball teams. The football team was elevated to NCAA Division III in 1979, its return into the NCAA since being revived 10 years earlier, and men’s basketball won the inaugural Eastern Collegiate Basketball League tournament and advanced to the 1977 NCAA Tournament, its most recent appearance before last March. Those Dukes have become something of legend among the Duquesne community, but Schmidt recalls differently as someone who covered them.

“A lot of people have a very romantic memory of the ‘76-’77 year and think, ‘yeah, they must’ve had a really good team,’ but they were 12-14 going into the [ECBL] tournament,” he said. “They swept through the tournament, but they were lucky UMass upset Rutgers, otherwise they would’ve had to play Rutgers.”

It would’ve been easy for Schmidt to write about the Pirates and Steelers, who both won their respective championships in 1979, but he was adamant about documenting Bluff sports as best as he could.

“We stayed away from the local professional stuff in terms of coverage and commentary,” Schmidt said. “We were so wrapped up in giving the Dukes the coverage we felt they deserved.”

Some of the sports Schmidt once used to fill up pages were discontinued in a controversial decision made by the university in 2010. Duquesne’s baseball, wrestling, men’s golf and men’s swimming teams were cut in order to re-allocate funding to other sports starting in the fall of that year. The Duke broke that story in the Jan. 28 issue.

“That was significant because it impacted so many people. You had alum and parents and so forth,” Steve Orbanek, who was sports editor at the time, said. “It was a dramatic, movie-style journalism. I remember meeting in the student union with wrestlers, who were there hours after they were cut, and they were going through everything they’d just heard, which they felt wasn’t presented to them as good as it could’ve been.”

Orbanek and his staff spent much of the rest of the semester breaking every new off-shoot of the story they could, even putting out an article that stated the university could have remained within its financial parameters while keeping the swim team.

“At the time you had the Post-Gazette and the Tribune-Review,” he said, “but nobody was covering it as hard and thorough as we were.”

Even through Duquesne athletics’ lean periods, the excitement in the newsroom to cover events was abundant. Matthew Pesyna was an editor in the late 1990s and did what he could to hit the road when he saw fit.

“My [assistant sports editor] Anthony Gargano and I loved traveling to road events when we could,” he said. “Obviously, the budget wasn’t there to make it happen often, but we usually just hopped in the car and turned it into a good time. D.C. and Loretto for football, Ohio State, Ann Arbor, Maryland and Philly for basketball, Covering the [MBB] Dukes against Maryland in 1999 was awesome. Cole Field House was a historical gem of a barn, and the Terps had Steve Francis, Juan Dixon and four other NBA guys on the roster. Duquesne went into that game 3-0, so there was a little hype. It didn’t end well — the game or the season, as the Dukes only won two games after the 3-0 start — but it was a great experience.”

Pesyna may not have had much winning or hard-hitting journalism to cover, but Orbanek summed up The Duke’s enthusiasm best.

“For a university that their success has been up and down, I think what’s remarkable is that despite all that is how devoted the Duke sports staff has been over the years. Last year, when we went to the tournament, we were all texting each other and had threads for every game. We were all bringing that up again. It’s a really neat thing. At least once a week, I think back to my time at The Duke.”

Leave a Comment