Ring statue drama and camaraderie in college

Eliyahu Gasson | opinions editor

*This article was origionally published on 2/27/2025. It was edited to correct an error on 2/28/2025. Corrections can be found here.

Two stories stood out to former editor-in-chief Kaye Burnet from her time at The Duquesne Duke.

The first was the controversy surrounding former Duquesne University President Charles J. Dougherty’s “libertine” comments. Readers can find a more detailed article about that story in the article titled “Dougherty reflects on ‘libertine lifestyle’ comment years later” on page 3.

The second was the controversy around the class ring statue that can be found in front of Rockwell Hall and Rangos School of Health Sciences. On Aug. 7, 2015, Burnet and Brandon Addeo published an investigative piece. The article looked into how much money the Student Government Association had spent on the statue and found that the installation would cost $20,000.

That number came from former Student Government Association Vice President of Finance Nicholas A. Hudak, who resigned over the summer break.

“I am providing this statement based on my belief that the student body has a right to know how the Student Government Association spends the money provided to it by the university as funded by students,” he told them in a written statement.

“They spent like thousands and thousands of dollars out of their budget, which was supposed to go to student activities on a massive ring statue,” Burnet said to The Duke.

The plaque currently on the back of the pedestal holding the ring statue does mention that it was sponsored by the SGA and Herff Jones, the company that makes the Duquesne University class ring, but it does not mention any former members of the SGA by name.

Burnet and Addeo’s article included a comment from former SGA President John Foster, who told them that he wasn’t able to confirm the cost of the statue because the organization’s bylaws required interested parties to submit a written request which would then need to be approved by 50% of the SGA senate. However, he insisted that no student money was allocated to the statue. Rather, he said, the money was taken from a separate pool of money raised by the SGA.

“That story was pretty fun to write and it felt like true journalism — like we were uncovering something that is relevant and interesting to the student body,” Burnet said.

The story’s publication was met with backlash from the SGA. Burnet said that she had to go to a mediation conversation with Foster because tensions between The Duke and the SGA had begun to run high.

In an email sent to The Duke on Wednesday by associate Vice President for Student Life Adam Wasilko, there was a push to create new traditions around the time the statue was funded. The ring statue itself was funded by Herff Jones and the base was funded by the SGA.

Wasilko doesn’t think the $20,000 price tag that the Duke reported on was accurate, but wasn’t able to confirm how much the SGA spent on the base.

“Prior to my work with the SGA they did not annually publish their budget, so it’s hard to say. I unfortunately don’t have the records from 10 years ago, as we keep budget information for seven years,” he said.

“There were some really good times,” Burnet said about her time working for The Duke. “There were also some stories that I look back on with some amount of regret where we had to publish corrections or something.”

Burnet admits that she didn’t always make the right calls as editor-in-chief, but the feedback she received from her peers at The Duke helped her do the job the best she could.

“I had a really good team of editors who made sure that we kept on the right track and having that camaraderie and that group of people was really impactful,” she said.

As editor-in-chief, Burnet took a field trip with the rest of The Duke staff to the Newseum in Washington, D.C., which closed in 2019.

“We just planned a road trip just for the fun of it for the staff of the newspaper because, I thought, other student groups do these things,” she said. “It was a very fun bonding experience for the newspaper staff.”

Leave a Comment