Identity crisis: What does it mean to be an American?

Josh Imhof | staff writer

As the country approaches three months since President Donald Trump’s second inauguration, the United States’ national identity has continued to grow weaker and shift more into extreme and authoritarian politics. In the past, we could have said our national ethos was democracy or freedom or the opportunity for upward mobility, but even that is a stretch because of current and past injustices regarding educational, racial and economic inequality.

Most Americans no longer understand the fundamentals of how the country functions, with more than 70% of 2,000 people not passing a basic civic literacy quiz in a 2023 study conducted by the U.S. Chamber of Commerce Foundation.

Even if they could, many believe these institutions were created with racist intent, with 70% of Black people believing that the U.S. judicial process holds them back and 67% believing the U.S. political system was designed to hold them back, according to a 2024 PEW Research Center study.

Income inequality continues to divide the nation as well, with America’s richest families having 248 times as much money as its poorest ones, according to another PEW study from 2016. This divide is not new, however, as it continues to get worse, it moves people’s definition of “normal” further and further away from each other.

For some, normal is waking up to take a 30-minute hot shower and walking downstairs to a full fridge. For others, it is boiling water to heat up a bathtub and forfeiting food out of necessity to make rent for the month.

These struggles make forming an overarching national identity difficult, something that is built on shared experiences, similar values, educational equality and cultural harmony. To compensate, the country relies heavily on the influence of famous people and corporations to create a superficial identity built on individualism and personal agendas. This is especially true among those less involved in current events.

The average American who does not read the news was significantly worse at identifying political figures than celebrities compared to their news-reading counterparts in a 2020 New York Times study. This is dangerous, as the people who actually have the power operate mostly behind the scenes, meaning that everyday people don’t have much to do with shaping identity.

Combine this with the fact that only 38% of Americans follow the news “most or all of the time” and you have a recipe for disaster.

Sure, the occasional “Barbenheimer” and “Brat” summer will temporarily distract and unite some of us, but these fads do very little to generate anything meaningful. Pop culture movements like these don’t have any staying power because they lack real significance. They won’t cause any sort of long term unity. They don’t further the nation with common goals, but are instead passing trends based on superficial values.

“Barbenheimer” encouraged people to look past the deeper meanings of both movies and instead focus on the materialistic trends based around them, which distracted some from substantive conversations about both films.

“Barbie” had a strong message of female empowerment and was a case study on how traditional gender roles affect society. “Oppenheimer” dealt with the moral repercussions of dropping the atomic bomb. Beyond driving box office success, these two movies had no reason to be tied together and in doing so it diluted both of their cultural impacts.

Thousands of people showing up to a film about the development and dropping of atomic bombs wearing pink cowboy hats and rhinestone boots is a clear sign that our cultural identity and values are more concerned with aesthetics than history and meaning.

On the other hand, “Brat” summer started off as a movement empowering individuals to embrace themselves and their flaws, but eventually degraded into a competition to see who could be the most independent and hedonistic. This is no way to build a strong identity either, as its values are constantly evolving and vary from person to person, allowing for broad interpretations of what they actually mean.

Both of these movements also relied heavily on social media, leaving non-users in the dark.

Despite the bleakness of today’s collective sense of identity, there is still hope for America. Throughout its almost 250 year history, the nation has shown time and time again that in times of struggle, the country is capable of looking out for each other.

During the Great Depression, community organizations and local governments invested in “thrift gardens,” providing residents with a reliable source of food when many could not afford it. These gardens highlighted the sense of duty Americans felt toward one another during a time of great suffering and created a common goal: survival.

Potlucks also became popular during this time, creating an identity of communal unity within the nation.

There are still glimpses of this communal identity today, however it often feels far and few between. In the face of new political, economic and social threats from the current administration, it is more important than ever for citizens to look out for each other and clearly define what it means to be American.

Leave a Comment