Long Cold Winter ahead for Cinderellas
Spencer Thomas | editor-in-chief
March Madness without the madness is just a month of wild changes in temperature. This NCAA tournament was one of the most predictable in recent memory. Four No. 1 seeds in the Final Four for the second time ever, and nobody better than a five-seed losing in the first round.
The only double-digit team to advance to the second weekend was coached by John Calipari. That’s not Cinderella. In the age of uncontrolled NIL, transfers and realignment, expect this trend to continue. Any talented player at a smaller school probably put his name in the portal this month, and rise to a bigger school. We saw this with Drake, one of the lowest-seeded schools to advance. The offseason before, they lost their coach and best player to West Virginia. Had they had continuity in those positions, they’d have been much better suited for a deeper run with more recognizable faces to capture fans’ interest.
Talent will constantly pool at the top of the sport and will not develop in lower programs. Fresh off a Final Four run in 2023, Florida Atlantic University ran it back with Head Coach Dusty May, and was an exciting prospect in March that ultimately flamed out in a thrilling overtime game. College basketball fans were lucky to see that bonus year, because last Spring everybody flew the coop.
May bailed to lead Michigan to the Elite Eight, and three starters from that game jumped to high-major programs. Despite having all their key pieces available for another year, the Owls had to rebuild, and went 18-16 this year and didn’t sniff the tournament. Even if as Owls pull from even smaller schools, the patchwork rebuild is less exciting for fans who lost the players they had fallen in love with, and they almost certainly won’t be able to capture the same magic they did two years ago.
Even if this March is an aberration in terms of tiny schools getting lucky to pick off power programs, a la Fairleigh Dickinson/Purdue, Oakland/Kentucky, what NIL definitively does is crush the multi-year surge of mid-majors who luck into a great coach and a solid recruiting class, and after a surprise run in March, have college basketball fans excited to follow them all of the next season. Extended runs like Wichita State and Dayton had in the mid-2010s are extinct.
Programs that would have once been considered Cinderellas rebuke that status when they jump to power conferences, like Houston and BYU. Had Houston stayed in the American Athletic Conference, it’d be much more exciting to follow them as they go into the Final Four this weekend. Instead, we’ll see a fantastic contest, but one that is missing its soul.
They still have to play the games
Michael O’Grady | sports editor
Those who have been watching the SEC Invitational — sorry, NCAA Tournament — have heard the name Chad Baker-Mazara often enough. Baker-Mazara is one of Auburn’s starters and best players, and little-known to the national audience is that he started his college career at Duquesne four seasons ago before transferring to San Diego State, JUCO Northwest Florida and now Auburn.
Paul Skenes and George Pickens are both younger than Baker-Mazara. Zion Williamson has played parts of what has felt like a lifetime of six years in the NBA, and he was drafted a full year before Baker-Mazara played a college game. Williamson is several months younger.
The best part about Baker-Mazara is that under new rules pertaining to JUCO transfers, he can actually return to Auburn for his age-26 season. The Tigers have been dominant this season and are indisputably one of the four best teams in the country, using the services of transfers like Baker-Mazara. In the age of NIL, it’s not promising for the rest of the field. But it’s no death knell.
For starters, experience doesn’t always translate to winning in college. According to Bart Torvik’s experience metric, Duke is the fourth-least experienced team in Division I, and it’s every bit as good as Auburn. Now, it’s Duke and it has the pick of the litter when it comes to recruiting, so take that with a grain of salt, but Torvik’s most experienced team was a mediocre Wichita State. None of its top-five players in games started began their careers in Wichita, they came from places like Saint Peter’s, Georgia and Oklahoma. All three were either in the tournament this year or last year.
The last time all four No. 1 seeds made it to the Final Four was in 2008, back when college hoops was supposedly much more balanced. Excluding a Jay Wright-coached Villanova team, there were three major upset stories: Siena over Vanderbilt, San Diego over UConn and of course Steph Curry’s Davidson made it all the way to the Elite Eight. That was it. Yet, there have been plenty since.
Truthfully, if this year is the extreme low, last year with similar circumstances was the extreme high. Yale beat Auburn, Grand Canyon beat Saint Mary’s, Oakland beat Kentucky, James Madison beat Wisconsin and obviously Duquesne beat BYU. And if the argument is none of these teams go on to win championships, then college basketball’s been broken since UNLV won a title in 1990 while playing in the Big West. A mid-major winning a title would be akin to Ipswich Town winning the UEFA Champions League. It can happen, it just doesn’t.
The madness is taking a break. It’ll be back.
