Biopics have a big problem with reality

Joshua Imhof
news editor | imhofj@duq.edu

The biopic “Bohemian Rhapsody” soared onto screens grossing more than $911 million in 2018 and even cruised to an Academy Award best picture nomination the following year.

The film follows the band Queen as they and lead singer Freddie Mercury took the world by storm in the 1970s and 1980s. It was a movie that had something for everyone.

For fans of Queen, the biopic fast-tracked through their greatest hits and gave a peek behind the curtain of one of the United Kingdom’s most successful bands. For audience members who had never listened to Queen’s music, there was an underdog-style story they could latch onto.

The film was fun, fast-paced and at times feel-good.

But it was also factually inaccurate.

Dates, like the year Mercury was diagnosed with AIDS, were switched out for the convenience of the plot. Characters who did not exist, like fictional record executive Ray Goss, were created out of thin air to drive conflict. Real-life events, like the band’s breakup and reconciliation for Live Aid in 1985, were embellished, altered or fabricated completely.

At the end of the day, a movie that is supposed to tell the true story of Queen tells a half-baked, warped version of events retroactively put together by the remaining members of the band and writer Anthony McCarten that rewrote most of its actual history.

So why does this matter eight years later?

When “Bohemian Rhapsody” was released, it did not invent the biopic genre. However, it proved to film studio executives that they could continue to severely alter facts and still make exorbitant amounts of money.

This is a dangerous proposition.

These biopics often end up shaping public opinion for their subjects by serving as an entry point for their history and driving the larger conversation around them.

This is not just true of movies. Social media, long-form videos and other online content also play a role in creating opinions on pop culture. However, when people spend a couple of hours with characters that are presented as protagonists, it can emotionally affect the viewer.

When these films manipulate facts, they are manipulating reality — especially, when these films are heavily marketed to be “based on a true story.”

This means they have an inherent responsibility to tell the truth. But this becomes muddled when films like “Bohemian Rhapsody” are produced, written and funded by those with a vested interest in how the movie portrays its subject.

Since the Queen biopic, other music pseudo-documentaries like “Elvis,” “Rocketman” and “A Complete Unknown” have dominated the box office as well as Oscar awards season.

These films all either had their actual subjects or members of the subject’s estate actively funding or getting final say over what was and was not included in the movie. This leads to skirting complexities and whitewashing parts of their history.

“Elvis” presents its subject as a sympathetic victim of the music industry, creating an idealized version of the character that is loosely true. But, it glosses over the murkier details of Elvis’ life like his numerous affairs and relationship with 14-year-old Priscilla Presley, who he would later marry.

One could argue that these details are not important to the story that the film is trying to tell. This is true to a certain point, but neglecting details that challenge the character of the person you are trying to portray is misleading.

If the whole point of your film is to paint someone as a sympathetic character, but you neglect things that would challenge the idea they are sympathetic, you are letting your audience down.

Still, the blame cannot entirely be placed on movie studios.

As consumers, it is also the audience’s responsibility to educate themselves on the actual details of the story. At this point, it is no secret that Hollywood stars and executives do not always have the best intentions.

With extensive biographies and online articles about the subjects of these films, there is no excuse for audiences to not look past the smoke screen and educate themselves.

But for casual viewers who may enjoy a band’s music or are just looking to escape for two hours, the likelihood of this happening diminishes.

For movies about musicians and bands, this is dangerous, but not the end of the world. At the end of the day, they are just a band.

However, when this same logic is applied to movies about important historical and political figures, the responsibility on both filmmakers and audiences to know the actual facts becomes even greater.

These films are able to have lasting effects on the real life political opinions of viewers, according to research published in the Social Science Quarterly. It stands to reason they also have lasting effects on the subjects of the film themselves.

For some biopics, this is the whole point.

Movies like “Oppenheimer” and the recently released “Primetime” tell a version of the story of their respective source material, but also put a heavy emphasis on tackling larger themes and ideas.

“Oppenheimer” discusses themes of guilt, mortality and morality through the lens of one of history’s most important scientists. “Primetime” questions how far is too far when it comes to punishing child predators and creating content for TV through an examination of Chris Hansen and his show “To Catch a Predator.”

The opinions of director Christopher Nolan and Lance Oppenheim, who directed “Oppenheimer” and “Primetime,” respectively, come out through their work and will now be associated with these people forever.

While biopics offer an often entertaining portrayal of their subjects, they can dangerously oversimplify the stories they try to tell in favor of narrative simplicity and historical whitewashing.

Even when filmmakers do not set out to get every fact correct, the people involved in those events get caught in the crossfire, leading public opinion of them to be dependent on their in-movie portrayal.

Viewers and filmmakers should take more time to realize that these are real-life people being discussed.

For all they know, one day, the lens could be turned on them.

Leave a Comment